Is lumbar disc surgery better with laser or open?

Last updated: October 19, 2025 The choice between open or laser disc surgery depends on the severity of the disc damage and the patient's condition. Laser surgery is less invasive, has a shorter recovery period and pain, and reduces the risk of infection; But for severe cases of disc herniation or extensive destruction, it has limited efficacy. In response to whether lumbar disc surgery is better with laser or open? It can be said that if the disc damage is severe, open surgery is a safer option because the doctor can directly take the pressure off the nerves. Although this method is more invasive and requires more time to heal, it is necessary in some cases. Therefore, the best surgical method is determined depending on the patient's condition and the doctor's diagnosis.

Which is more effective for lumbar disc surgery with laser or open surgery?

The effectiveness of lumbar disc surgery with laser or open surgery depends on the degree of disc damage and the patient's condition, and the cause of lower back pain must be investigated before each issue. Laser surgery is minimally invasive and effective for mild to moderate cases, but in severe cases, there is a possibility of recurrence of the herniated disc. In contrast, open surgery, although more invasive, has a longer-term effect and shows better results in patients with serious injuries. About whether lumbar disc surgery is better with laser or open?

It can be said that in cases where the disc herniation is extensive, open surgery has a more lasting result. To choose the right method, it is necessary to consult with the best lumbar disc surgeon in Tehran or other provinces so that the best treatment option can be selected based on the patient's condition.

Comparison of the benefits of open lumbar disc surgery with laser therapy method

Among lumbar disc treatment methods comparing the benefits of open lumbar disc surgery with laser therapy can help patients choose the best treatment method with more knowledge. The choice between these two methods will vary depending on the severity of the disc damage, the general condition of the patient and the treatment goals. In the table below, you can see the most important differences between these two methods:

Feature Lumbar disc surgery Lumbar disc operation with laser Use cases Severe disc herniation, advanced injuries Small to medium hernias Amount of access to the affected area Direct and complete access Limited and targeted access Duration of recovery longer shorter Need anesthesia Complete anesthesia Usually local or partial anesthesia Risk of bleeding and infection More than the laser method Less because of minimal invasiveness Success rate in advanced problems up Limited in severe cases Possibility of disease recurrence less It may be higher in some cases

The final choice between open lumbar disc surgery or laser treatment should be made based on careful consultation with a specialist doctor. In severe herniations and extensive disc destruction, open surgery is usually a more suitable option, while for milder injuries, the laser procedure can be preferred due to the short recovery period and fewer complications.

Complications of open lumbar disc surgery

Longer recovery period: weeks to months required for full recovery
Creating a surgical scar: Larger incisions can cause permanent scarring
Risk of infection: the possibility of infection in the surgical area due to the open wound
Damage to surrounding muscles and tissues: surgery may result in long-term weakness or pain
Danger of nerve adhesions: scarred tissues may adhere to nerves and cause pain
Possibility of blood clots: Decreased mobility after surgery can cause thrombosis
Recurrence of the disc problem: in some cases, the patient will face the same problems again after a few years

Complications of lumbar disc surgery with laser

Less effective in severe cases: This method is less effective for large herniated discs or damaged discs
Possibility of needing re-surgery: in some patients, symptoms reappear after a few months
Possibility of nerve damage: Improper use of laser can damage nerve tissues
Uncertain long-term results: insufficient data on durability of results compared to open surgery
Impossibility of complete removal of the damaged disc: in cases where the disc is severely damaged, the laser is not capable of complete removal
Higher cost: Due to the use of more advanced equipment, the cost of the operation may be higher than open surgery

Difference in the cost of lumbar disc surgery with laser and open surgery

Lumbar disc surgery cost with laser is usually higher than open surgery, because more advanced technology, special equipment and specialists with special skills are used. On the other hand, open surgery is less expensive due to using more traditional methods and performing it in general medical centers. However, hospitalization costs and longer recovery times can increase the overall cost of open surgery.

For lumbar disc surgery in the elderly, side costs such as post-operative care and physiotherapy sessions should also be considered, as the recovery period is longer in this group. Finally, the choice of surgical method depends on various factors such as the severity of the disease, the financial ability of the patient and the doctor's opinion.

Lumbar disc treatment with open surgery or laser, which one should we choose?

For your easier and better choice between these two options, we have told you the opinion of an expert in the field of lumbar disc treatment below.

Dr. Paul C. McCormick, a prominent spine surgeon and professor at Columbia University

According to a 2024 review, about 70% of patients with severe herniated discs who underwent open lumbar disc surgery achieved complete recovery within 12 months of surgery, while the success rate of laser treatment for milder herniations was reported to be about 85%. The correct choice between these two methods should be made based on the severity of the injury and the general condition of the spine.

Comprehensive comparison of open lumbar disc surgery with laser lumbar disc surgery

In general, in checking whether lumbar disc surgery is better with laser or open? It can be said that open lumbar disc surgery is usually recommended for patients with more severe injuries, because it allows the complete removal of the damaged disc and reducing the pressure on the nerves. On the other hand, lumbar disc surgery with laser is less invasive, less painful and has a shorter recovery period for the patient; However, this method is not suitable for all patients, and in severe cases, its effect will be less than open surgery.

Dr. Mahmoud Yazdan Panahi advises patients to do expert consultation before choosing a treatment method and to consider all aspects including the success rate, possible side effects and post-operative needs.

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest

Dr. Yazdan Panahi

Student of Shahid Beheshti University of Tehran. The top rank of the specialized board of neurosurgery. 7-year history of performing complex operations on the base of the skull and brain and spinal cord tumors, 7-year history of complex operations on the spine

Spine and spinal cord

Lumbar disc treatment at home 14 ways to treat lumbar disc at home

Many people prefer to try less risky methods such as lumbar disc treatment at home before undergoing surgery. These methods include medication, physical therapy exercises, limited rest, light physical activity, massage, and techniques such as chiropractic. They aim to reduce inflammation, relieve pain and improve movement, and if done correctly, can speed up the healing process. Stay with us to check more of these items.